Contractor Guides Contractors

IR35 reforms for private sector – consultation released

Businesses to be responsible for sorting out status disputes, notes Larsen Howie’s new Head of Tax Andy Vessey. A little…

Andy Vessey by Andy Vessey

Businesses to be responsible for sorting out status disputes, notes Larsen Howie’s new Head of Tax Andy Vessey.

A little quicker off the mark than many had anticipated, HMRC have published the consultation document ‘Off-payroll working rules from April 2020‘ which will run for 85 days, closing on 28th May 2019.

Ostensibly, the off-payroll rules will mirror those currently in place for the public sector but with some tweaks. This is because the government acknowledges that the needs of private sector organisations are different to those in the public sector, and that the range of activities carried out are much more diverse.

The extension of the existing rules to cover independent contractor usage is due to begin on 6th April 2020, with the consultation making it clear that the public sector rules will serve as the starting point when the private sector rollout begins.This consultation period is intended to gather comments from stakeholders on the proposals put forward by HMRC.

Here’s what you need to know.

Who will be affected?

Only medium and large-sized organisations will have to consider whether or not the off-payroll rules apply to an engagement as from April 2020. It is the government’s intention to use the definition of a small company as the yard stick for measuring if a company is small or not. This is contained in S.382 Companies Act 2006, which states that a company qualifies as ‘small’ if it satisfies two or more of the following requirements in a year:

  1. Annual turnover of not more than £10.2M
  2. Balance sheet total of not more than £5.1M
  3. Number of employees of not more than 50

Companies in small groups, as defined by S.383 Companies Act 2006, will also qualify as ‘small’.

To prevent parties that are connected to, associated with, or controlled by the end client, from taking advantage of the small companies exemption, anti-avoidance measures will be considered.

What about non-corporate end clients?

As the Companies Act definition does not apply to non-corporate entities, the consultation document proposes two options, albeit by reference to that definition:

  1. An organisation with 50 or more employees or with a turnover in excess of £10.2M; or
  2. An organisation has 50 or more employees and a turnover in excess of £10.2M.

Both tests would be measured on an annual basis in the same way as the Companies Act test.

When an organisation becomes, or ceases to be small in an accounting period, for the purposes of the off-payroll rules, that change will apply from the start of the tax year following the end of that accounting period regardless of whether they are incorporated or not.

Small organisations

PSCs contracting to small organisations in the private sector will remain responsible for assessing their own IR35 risk.

Where a potential fee-payer has not received a determination, it will not be required to make any PAYE tax and NIC deductions.

Tell it to the worker

There is currently no requirement for the end client to provide the contractor with a determination of their status nor for the worker or fee-payer to seek the reasons for a decision.

Legislative changes will therefore be made to ensure that the determination and reasons for such is disseminated to all parties within the contractual chain. This will be backed up with clear guidance.

The government understands that end-clients regularly provide fee-payers with determinations within the public sector.

Transfer of debt

Where HMRC does not receive the PAYE tax and NIC, it is proposed that the liability should initially rest with the party that has failed to fulfil its obligations until such time that it does. This means that liability would move down the contractual chain as each party fulfils its obligations.

For example, if an agency in a chain failed to pass on a determination, that agency would be liable for the tax and NIC. Similarly, if a fee-payer, having received the determination failed to make the necessary PAYE and NIC deductions, then it would become liable.

Where HMRC are unable to collect tax and NIC arrears from one party, e.g. because it ceased to exist, then the document proposes that the debt should transfer back to the first party or agency in the chain. Where this is not possible, then the end client would be left holding the baby.

Resolving status disputes

Making blanket assessments based on a role or on a group of contractors working in the same role is simply the wrong approach. HMRC, however, believe this may be appropriate in some circumstances. This would only be acceptable to the department where IR35 was found to apply and not the other way around, of course.

The document suggests that where a role and contract have been previously assessed as inside the off-payroll rules, an organisation can be in a position to determine the status of the role at the time of advertising. Wrong! This is pre-determination but something that HMRC are very good at when it comes to IR35.

There is currently no formal appeal process whereby a contractor can challenge a determination by the end client but the government believes that by making it compulsory for the end user to provide the contractor with this information, and the reasons for reaching their conclusion, then this will go some way to addressing this concern.

Whilst this helps, it certainly doesn’t resolve the issue.

Rather than putting in place a formal appeal process, the government is passing the buck to the end client. Organisations would therefore need to put in place a process which allowed for their decisions to be challenged where necessary.

As a minimum, such a process would have to include evidence offered by the contractor and/or fee-payer. This may not be such a bad thing, as end users may be more persuaded by rational argument than HMRC are.

As justification for this proposal, the government’s view is that the end client will have met its duty to take reasonable care in reaching a status decision.

Contracted-out services

The off-payroll rules do not apply where a public authority has fully contracted out services to a third party, e.g. an outsourcing company, where the workers do not personally provide their services to the end user.

This will continue to be the case for both the private and public sector from April 2020, although the consultation document states that the third party will be required to consider the application of the off-payroll rules and, where the rules apply, to deduct and pay the appropriate tax and NIC.

Surely though, this should only be the case where the third party is not ‘small’?

CEST tool

Since CEST was launched in 2017, it has come under much justified criticism due to it not taking account of existing case law and ignoring a number of employment status tests. HMRC is currently working to improve both the tool and guidance so that status decisions can be understood and made with some degree of confidence.

Pensions

Legislative options are to be considered to allow fee-payers to make pension contributions free of tax and NIC to the workers’ personal pension but how likely is this to be taken up?

Implications for recruiters

It would be wise for recruitment agencies to keep a close eye on the proposed reform. As the Legal Manager of Kingsbridge Contractor Insurance Nicola Hayman notes:

“The new transfer of debt provision proposed in the consultation is a positive step towards transparency and compliance in the recruitment supply chain and should help reduce the involvement of unscrupulous companies. However, it comes with an added burden to the agency/MSP who hold the contract with the end client.

If there is failure to remit PAYE tax and NICs the liability can transfer back to the first party or agency in the chain. This company ‘Intermediary 1’ will have a significant role to play in protecting themselves, their agencies and their clients by ensuring that their process is fully compliant and poses zero risk to everyone involved.”

Andy Robinson, Head of Business Development at Kingsbridge Contactor Insurance, echoed those calls and emphasised the benefits of nurturing a compliance culture:

“Following the correct compliance procedures can give recruitment agencies a significant competitive advantage over their competitors. Alongside reduced levels of balance sheet and litigation risk, a compliant agency will also find itself to be a much more attractive offering for MSPs and RPOs and will have an improved likelihood of passing end client audits.”

Take action now

Those end client businesses that will be affected by the changes in April 2020 should be preparing for the reform now, by:

  • Identifying the number of contractors they engage;
  • Identifying the tax and NIC risk;
  • Reviewing the current contractual and working arrangements between themselves and the workers engaged via PSC’s;
  • Putting in place robust and consolidated processes for assessing and arriving at consistent decisions about the employment status of contractors; and
  • Reviewing internal systems, such as payroll software and on-boarding processes and making changes, where necessary.

Related topics

Contractor Guides Contractors

You might also like...

Back to resources
Close up photo of female worker at a desk with laptop and calculator, representing article on what insurance contractors need
Contractor Guides Contractors 03 Nov 2026

What insurance contractors need?

We know it can be a minefield for contractors when it comes to purchasing the right contractor insurance to protect…

Image of a handheld drill on a work bench, representing guide on how to insure work tools for tradespeople
Trades Trades Life 09 Sep 2026

How to insure your tools: a tradesperson’s guide

Most tradespeople spend a lot of time thinking about the next job, the next customer, or the next challenge on…

A flat lay of a desk with stationery and notebook with writing 'insurance checklist', representing guide on questions to ask when buying contractor insurance
Contractor Guides Contractors 24 Aug 2026

7 things to ask before buying contractor insurance

Buying contractor insurance isn’t exactly the most exciting item on your to-do list.  When you’re focused on winning contracts, meeting…

Image of tradesman leaning against white van looking at insurance quotes on his phone, representing article discussing cheap tradesmen insurance
Trades Trades Life 28 Jul 2026

Cheap trades insurance: how low is too low?

When you’re running your own trades business, it’s only natural to try and keep costs to a minimum. But for…

Photo of protest crowd in london, representing article on loan charge review scandal
Contractors News 15 Jul 2026

Why the Loan Charge scandal isn’t going away

In the late 1990s, loan-based remuneration schemes began to emerge before becoming widespread among contractors and freelancers during the 2000s.…

Image of tradesman's arm being bandaged, representing article on employers' liability insurance for tradespeople
Trades Trades Life 07 Jul 2026

Do tradesmen need employers’ liability insurance?

If you’re a tradesman running your own business, you might assume employers’ liability insurance only applies to corporate companies. But…

Contractors News 19 Jun 2026

The tax, pension and savings changes UK contractors need to keep on top of

The 2026/27 tax year might not be bringing one dramatic overhaul, but it marks the beginning of a multi-year shift…

Photo of dug out earth with construction worker on mini excavator, representing article on plant and machinery insurance
Trades Trades Life 01 Jun 2026

What is plant and machinery insurance?

From diggers and dumpers to cement mixers and compressors, plant and machinery are the backbone of many trades. Whether you’re…

Close-up of dates on a green calendar, representing article discussing claims made vs claims occurring in business insurance
Contractor Guides Contractors 26 May 2026

Simplifying insurance: what is claims made vs claims occurring

When you’re choosing insurance, you’ll often come across two terms: claims made and claims occurring. They both refer to the…

Tradesmen tools laid out on table, representing article on tool theft stories and keeping tools safe
Trades Trades Life 20 May 2026

Tool theft stories: tradespeople going beyond locks to keep tools safe

As tool theft continues to dominate headlines and social feeds, many tradespeople are no longer relying on standard security –…

Goodie bag from Powered Now Advice on Tap event, representing article on tradespeoples' concerns about tool insurance claims
Trades Trades Life 15 May 2026

Powered Now ‘Advice on Tap’: trade talk and tool theft troubles

Powered Now’s landmark event brings together tradespeople of all backgrounds. But conversations highlight the ongoing issue of tool theft, the…

Photo of builders discussing construction plans, representing article on what professional indemnity means for tradespeople
Trades Trades Life 28 Apr 2026

What is professional indemnity for tradespeople?

Many tradesmen assume professional indemnity is only for people with a desk job. But in reality, if your work involves…

Image of two builders carrying construction materials, representing article on do subcontrctors need their own insurance
Trades Trades Life 15 Apr 2026

Do subcontractors need their own insurance?

Knowing whether subcontractors need their own insurance can be confusing. Whether working in construction, roofing, plumbing, electrical work or specialist…

Image of construction hard hats representing a guide to what insurance a tradesman needs
Trades Trades Life 31 Mar 2026

What insurance does a tradesman need?

Insurance sounds like a good idea, but how do you know what insurance you need as a tradesman? No two…

Photo of a presentation screen at an event held by Kingsbridge on the JSL legislation and what it means for recruitment agencies
Partner News Partners 30 Mar 2026

What JSL will mean for you: Five lessons from our expert panel

Earlier this month Kingsbridge brought together a panel of industry experts to discuss the implications of the government’s new JSL…

Builder working on a house extension roof, representing a guide to contract works insurance for tradespeople including what it covers
Trades Trades Life 17 Mar 2026

What is contract works insurance?

However big or small your construction project is, contract works insurance could be a lifesaver if something happens. When you’re…

Image of bricklaying representing article on who needs trades insurance and what it covers
Trades Trades Life 10 Mar 2026

Who needs trades insurance?

If you work in the trades, chances are you’ve already heard people chatting about tradesman insurance, but have been left…

Calendar with date circled, representing guide on what a retroactive date is in professional indemnity insurance
Contractor Guides Contractors 26 Feb 2026

Professional indemnity insurance: what’s a retroactive date

Whether you’ve just taken out a professional indemnity policy or you’re shopping for new business insurance, chances are you’ve come…

HMRC Making Tax Digital campaign asset, representing article disucssing the upcoming changes for sole traders April 2026
Contractor Guides Contractors 16 Feb 2026

A ‘Making Tax Digital’ wake-up call for sole traders

The way Britain pays tax is entering its biggest modernisation in a generation, with Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income…

Photo of HMRC London offices representing article discussing the Employment Rights Act 2025 being law, what changes it brings and what businesses need to do now
Partner News Partners 22 Jan 2026

Employment Rights Act 2025 ‘brings world of work into 21st century’

Big changes to the world of work have been on the horizon for a while and the Royal Assent of…

HMRC Self Assessment tax return letter for 2025 tax year sent to UK taxpayer with UTR and NINO
Contractor Guides Contractors 16 Jan 2026

Online Self Assessment tax return deadline: what to know for 2026 (and beyond)

If you’re required to file a Self Assessment tax return for the 2024/25 tax year, the deadline to submit it…

Contractor Guides Contractors 01 Jan 2026

What is the difference between a sole trader and a limited company?

One of the big questions for any contractor when they first set up as self-employed is whether you should operate as a…

Image of sparks caused by power tools, representing article on what makes a trade high risk for insurance
Trades Trades Life 18 Dec 2025

Trades cover: who’s considered high risk for insurance

If you’re in the trades, you already know the job isn’t without its risks. But did you know those risks…