IR35 Hub Partners

IR35 and Personal Service: why the right to substitution is so important

Out of the three major IR35 employment status tests – the other two being mutuality of obligation (MOO) and client…

Kingsbridge by Kingsbridge

Out of the three major IR35 employment status tests – the other two being mutuality of obligation (MOO) and client control – personal service is often the trickiest.

It can easily swing an IR35 investigation in the right direction should a contractor be able demonstrate a lack of personal service to provide a substitute, and it’s a relatively easy issue to fix within a contract. However, thanks to miseducation and a lot of murky caselaw, it’s easy to see why recruiters, end clients, and contractors alike get confused over this particular test.

What exactly is personal service, or ‘substitution’, and how can it effect an IR35 status decision?

What is personal service, or substitution?

The main difference between a contractor and an employee is that when a contractor is engaged, it’s their specific services and skills being paid for – if they need time off sick, they can ask an equally qualified contractor to take up those services and skills in their absence. An employee, however, is paid for their time to complete a number of day-to-day jobs, and in many cases couldn’t simply send someone else to fill their role at work for the day.

Let’s give some context. If you were to call an engineer to carry out an on-site audit for your ongoing building work,call a plumber to fix a leaking boiler, would you care if it was specifically the engineer plumber you spoke to on the phone that carried out the work, or just someone qualified? This is the right to substitution and is a good test of if a contractor is genuine.

Ask yourself if a contractor could realistically supply a substitute to do their role. If no, then their personal service is required, as an employee would be, and it could mean the difference between landing inside or outside IR35.

Eamonn Holmes lost his IR35 tribunal due to substitution

Red, White & Green Ltd (RWG), Eamonn Holmes’ personal service company (PSC) through which he provided most of his presenting services to the likes of ITV and Sky, was first brought to tribunal back in June 2018. Holmes lost his IR35 appeal, with the judge ruling in HMRC’s favour that he was indeed a so-called ‘disguised employee’. The amount of tax owed could be as much as £250,000, as reported by the Daily Mail, and his lack of a substitute contributed heavily to that ruling.

Holmes accepted that ITV wanted his services specifically and that he wasn’t permitted to provide a replacement even in theory (which is often how the right to substitution is accepted when considering employment status). If he couldn’t provide his services, it was up to ITV to find someone else to take his place, as an employer would have to.

There’re certainly grounds to claim that Holmes was selling a specific ‘personality’ or ‘brand’ as part of their services like fellow presenter Lorraine Kelly (who managed to win her own IR35 tribunal shortly before Eamon’s). However, Kelly did, in fact, supply a substitute on occasion, whom she chose, organised, and paid for herself. In Holmes’ case, the broadcaster specifically wanted his services and stipulated that Holmes’ participation was ‘integral to the programme and a material term of the agreement’.

How can I avoid falling foul of personal service in an IR35 tribunal?

Firstly, it’s important to communicate openly throughout the supply chain to make sure everyone is educated about IR35 and understands the implications to an ‘inside’ determination. Whether that’s recommending some professional consultation consultancy to an end client or asking contractors to have a third-party employment status test carried out, it’s important that everyone is on the same wavelength before attempting to negotiate a change of contract wording.

Secondly, have a frank discussion with whoever may be affected by any personal service within a contract and look honestly at whether there could be expectations that aren’t fair to the contractor. Does the end client want the contractor to work for them like an employee? Perhaps they have a specific ‘no substitute’ clause like ITV stipulated for Eamonn Holmes? Making some small wording changes within a contract can be the difference between a happy, mutually beneficial working relationship or a substantial tax debt.

Lastly, many people misunderstand this particular status test to mean that a contractor must have a viable substitute waiting in the wings. The idea of a substitute is largely hypothetical; if a client would accept a suitable substitute in theory to fill the skills of an absent contractor, then that’s good enough to show that no personal service is expected and that they are genuinely self-employed.

How to prepare for the 2021 IR35 reform

For the time being, the delay to the private sector IR35 reform (which you can read more about here) dictates that contractors must determine their own employment status for another year – this means that the liability of a wrong determination still sits with the contractor for that time too.

It’s crucial that all points of the supply chains understand their IR35 position with every contract taken on or filled. Getting a professional contract and working practices review is pivotal to making sure you know where you stand, while IR35 investigation insurance is also a worthy investment and can provide a lifeline should you fall foul of an HMRC enquiry.

A good policy will include an IR35 status review, as well as cover for the unpaid tax debts, interest, fines, and legal fees, and will flex with the reform roll out to cover the contractor, recruiter, and end client. Our IR35 Protect product offers the above in one comprehensive package.

For more information on how Kingsbridge can assist your business in preparing for off-payroll 2021, please email [email protected]

Related topics

IR35 Hub Partners

You might also like...

Back to resources
Close up photo of female worker at a desk with laptop and calculator, representing article on what insurance contractors need
Contractor Guides Contractors 03 Nov 2026

What insurance contractors need?

We know it can be a minefield for contractors when it comes to purchasing the right contractor insurance to protect…

Image of a handheld drill on a work bench, representing guide on how to insure work tools for tradespeople
Trades Trades Life 09 Sep 2026

How to insure your tools: a tradesperson’s guide

Most tradespeople spend a lot of time thinking about the next job, the next customer, or the next challenge on…

A flat lay of a desk with stationery and notebook with writing 'insurance checklist', representing guide on questions to ask when buying contractor insurance
Contractor Guides Contractors 24 Aug 2026

7 things to ask before buying contractor insurance

Buying contractor insurance isn’t exactly the most exciting item on your to-do list.  When you’re focused on winning contracts, meeting…

Image of tradesman leaning against white van looking at insurance quotes on his phone, representing article discussing cheap tradesmen insurance
Trades Trades Life 28 Jul 2026

Cheap trades insurance: how low is too low?

When you’re running your own trades business, it’s only natural to try and keep costs to a minimum. But for…

Photo of protest crowd in london, representing article on loan charge review scandal
Contractors News 15 Jul 2026

Why the Loan Charge scandal isn’t going away

In the late 1990s, loan-based remuneration schemes began to emerge before becoming widespread among contractors and freelancers during the 2000s.…

Image of tradesman's arm being bandaged, representing article on employers' liability insurance for tradespeople
Trades Trades Life 07 Jul 2026

Do tradesmen need employers’ liability insurance?

If you’re a tradesman running your own business, you might assume employers’ liability insurance only applies to corporate companies. But…

Contractors News 19 Jun 2026

The tax, pension and savings changes UK contractors need to keep on top of

The 2026/27 tax year might not be bringing one dramatic overhaul, but it marks the beginning of a multi-year shift…

Photo of dug out earth with construction worker on mini excavator, representing article on plant and machinery insurance
Trades Trades Life 01 Jun 2026

What is plant and machinery insurance?

From diggers and dumpers to cement mixers and compressors, plant and machinery are the backbone of many trades. Whether you’re…

Close-up of dates on a green calendar, representing article discussing claims made vs claims occurring in business insurance
Contractor Guides Contractors 26 May 2026

Simplifying insurance: what is claims made vs claims occurring

When you’re choosing insurance, you’ll often come across two terms: claims made and claims occurring. They both refer to the…

Tradesmen tools laid out on table, representing article on tool theft stories and keeping tools safe
Trades Trades Life 20 May 2026

Tool theft stories: tradespeople going beyond locks to keep tools safe

As tool theft continues to dominate headlines and social feeds, many tradespeople are no longer relying on standard security –…

Goodie bag from Powered Now Advice on Tap event, representing article on tradespeoples' concerns about tool insurance claims
Trades Trades Life 15 May 2026

Powered Now ‘Advice on Tap’: trade talk and tool theft troubles

Powered Now’s landmark event brings together tradespeople of all backgrounds. But conversations highlight the ongoing issue of tool theft, the…

Photo of builders discussing construction plans, representing article on what professional indemnity means for tradespeople
Trades Trades Life 28 Apr 2026

What is professional indemnity for tradespeople?

Many tradesmen assume professional indemnity is only for people with a desk job. But in reality, if your work involves…

Image of two builders carrying construction materials, representing article on do subcontrctors need their own insurance
Trades Trades Life 15 Apr 2026

Do subcontractors need their own insurance?

Knowing whether subcontractors need their own insurance can be confusing. Whether working in construction, roofing, plumbing, electrical work or specialist…

Image of construction hard hats representing a guide to what insurance a tradesman needs
Trades Trades Life 31 Mar 2026

What insurance does a tradesman need?

Insurance sounds like a good idea, but how do you know what insurance you need as a tradesman? No two…

Photo of a presentation screen at an event held by Kingsbridge on the JSL legislation and what it means for recruitment agencies
Partner News Partners 30 Mar 2026

What JSL will mean for you: Five lessons from our expert panel

Earlier this month Kingsbridge brought together a panel of industry experts to discuss the implications of the government’s new JSL…

Builder working on a house extension roof, representing a guide to contract works insurance for tradespeople including what it covers
Trades Trades Life 17 Mar 2026

What is contract works insurance?

However big or small your construction project is, contract works insurance could be a lifesaver if something happens. When you’re…

Image of bricklaying representing article on who needs trades insurance and what it covers
Trades Trades Life 10 Mar 2026

Who needs trades insurance?

If you work in the trades, chances are you’ve already heard people chatting about tradesman insurance, but have been left…

Calendar with date circled, representing guide on what a retroactive date is in professional indemnity insurance
Contractor Guides Contractors 26 Feb 2026

Professional indemnity insurance: what’s a retroactive date

Whether you’ve just taken out a professional indemnity policy or you’re shopping for new business insurance, chances are you’ve come…

HMRC Making Tax Digital campaign asset, representing article disucssing the upcoming changes for sole traders April 2026
Contractor Guides Contractors 16 Feb 2026

A ‘Making Tax Digital’ wake-up call for sole traders

The way Britain pays tax is entering its biggest modernisation in a generation, with Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income…

Photo of HMRC London offices representing article discussing the Employment Rights Act 2025 being law, what changes it brings and what businesses need to do now
Partner News Partners 22 Jan 2026

Employment Rights Act 2025 ‘brings world of work into 21st century’

Big changes to the world of work have been on the horizon for a while and the Royal Assent of…

HMRC Self Assessment tax return letter for 2025 tax year sent to UK taxpayer with UTR and NINO
Contractor Guides Contractors 16 Jan 2026

Online Self Assessment tax return deadline: what to know for 2026 (and beyond)

If you’re required to file a Self Assessment tax return for the 2024/25 tax year, the deadline to submit it…

Contractor Guides Contractors 01 Jan 2026

What is the difference between a sole trader and a limited company?

One of the big questions for any contractor when they first set up as self-employed is whether you should operate as a…

Image of sparks caused by power tools, representing article on what makes a trade high risk for insurance
Trades Trades Life 18 Dec 2025

Trades cover: who’s considered high risk for insurance

If you’re in the trades, you already know the job isn’t without its risks. But did you know those risks…